Micki,
In regards to the intern's language barrier/issues (and also the
hearing-impairment accommodation)...it sounds like you are on the right track with all
addressing this. The journal is a great idea because the written communication
will serve to enhance the verbal.
Part of what your intern is going through with the language issue -is the
same nervousness and insecurity many new interns experience, but it is being
expressed and is exhibited through the second language.
As for her insecurity with English - I had supervised a student in a similar
situation. In that case, no one could really understand his English, because
he also spoke very quietly and mumbled as a result of the insecurity. Turns
out that his spoken English was fine!
First thing I had to do was to encourage him to speak more and to speak up.
In order to do this of course, we engaged in regular conversations. Asking him
questions, allowing him to respond, providing plenty of opportunity to
contribute to and initiate conversation was very important.
For answering the telephone and responding to questions, providing
interpretive info. etc., I had him shadow me when I was engaged in such. Then, I had
him rehearse with me and even had him pick up the phone and practice with no
one on the other end. Another time, I called him from another phone line and we
did a 'dry run'.
It was also important that I let him speak without interrupting to correct
him. Anything that I overheard that needed to be corrected -I talked with him
afterward. Not soon after that, I made sure he had ever opportunity to provide
information without me hovering nearby, and this encouraged him to ask
questions and obtain confidence in working independently.
But there was more -I noticed that other students, volunteers and interns
never or rarely spoke to or with him. Though I suspected the language barrier
was the reason for this, none-the-less I asked the students why they never
spoke to him. Asking them this - created the forum for discussion. Knowing what
their response was going to be, I was prepared to offer suggestions. And, as I
suspected, they told me it was because they couldn't understand him when he
spoke.
I encouraged them to speak with him freely -as if they would speak with
anyone else, and that they would help him greatly in doing so. (this last part
really motivated the students!). By following my advice, they 'included' him in
conversations and I watched his spoken English and confidence improve. Also
to get the ball rolling - I had to be the group facilitator. When the
students were sitting together at a table and working on their projects, I brought
in my work (or came in to check on theirs) to join them and started
discussions about work-related topics, academic issues, chit chat.
In order to meet project completion goals and encourage productivity, it was
important that all the students and others work well as a team. So some of
the students - I had to provide extra attention and training for whatever
reason and for many, this was their first time working anyway. Inter and intra
personal skills were a part of this. And overall, I needed to create and
maintain a non-hostile work environment (including no peer pressure).
For the hearing impairment - it is important to address all potential
accommodations. While I've been discussing the issues of students I supervised at
one place I worked - at the same place my own supervisor was hearing-impaired
and wore hearing aids.
One thing my supervisor told me was that even with hearing aids he could not
pick up sound coming from behind him. And being able to follow and read lips
and facial expression was very helpful to him too.
I also found out that at times when he could not hear me...intentionally
because he turned down or off the volume on his hearing aids. I tried not to
take that personally! And when he would be singing (like everyday) I sometimes
wished I had the same option. lol I did grown accustomed to his voice.
Do you think there's a possibility that the manager has given the intern the
title and charge of Curator because they feel sorry for the intern? If so,
or even if that isn't the reason...I don't think it is inappropriate. I can
only think of positive things attributed to this appointment. Not that your
concerns aren't justifiable. All in all, she is just there 8 hours a week, the
position is not full-time permanent and she is not getting salary and benefits
comparable to yours.
I see where you are conflicted, especially as you point out the interns'
lack of the proper educational and work background to even be considered for an
appointment to the position of curator. And not be referred to in the title
as an 'intern' - may bring about confusion to visitor's, volunteers and
others... so I think that should be addressed.
I don't know what I could suggest to you about your resentment, regarding
the work and time you committed as an unpaid intern. There's always going to be
others who have had a 'lesser' experience/sacrifice and vice-versa. Museum
work is, besides being competitive for those with the credentials still a
field where one can obtain an (ahem) appointment.
For this part - ikes because of my own employment (barely) situation I have
to refrain from saying or thinking too much about your situation. I want to be
empathetic...um....there's a possibility that many of us may be even more
qualified or have sacrificed even much more than you and we don't have jobs or
permanent full-time jobs with bennies.
Guess I'm trying to say that your resentment is subjective so I really can't
suggest, comment or otherwise in an objective manner because of that, and
because of my own circumstances. All I can do is wish you well in working
through that and encourage you to do so of course.
Pam
In a message dated 10/1/2005 3:53:59 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
[log in to unmask] writes:
I am currently setting up a work schedule in our community history museum
archives with a first-time intern who has coursework in museum studies under
her belt. I am looking forward to this relationship, but have some sensitive
questions to ask of those with more experience. I have trained interns
before, but under a contract with a school who had specific measurements for
each intern. Through our one-on-one close working relationship, this intern
is getting the hands-on practicum missing in her museum studies program. We
are primarily working in collections and archives management, but I am also
training her to do oral histories in the community in preparation for
interpretive exhibits.
This intern is eager and willing and will be a great asset, but I am
concerned about her insecurity in using English (her second language). Way
back when I was an intern, I found the technique of keeping an intern
project journal to be very helpful. I kept it as more of a diary and entered
every question into it, and my museum studies supervisor would read through
it once or twice a month and would give specific feedback in those areas
where I was unsure. It was nearly instant feedback and took care of what
might have otherwise developed into problems, since my own intern experience
did not include direct museum supervision.
I will be meeting with this intern to define her project together on October
4th, and would like some feedback from this discussion group: would you
advise me to set up a similar intern journal system with this intern? She is
amenable to and requests correction of her misuse of the language, and I
thought it might be a good way to catch misinformation, misunderstandings
and misspellings fairly instantly (I would ask her to go over the week's
work with me, and to point out things she felt insecure about). The last
thing I want to imply is that she is incapable--she certainly is not. I
think of the working relationship as two-way communication, because one of
her extremely valuable assets is as an interpreter/translator for labels and
outreach. I need her world view as much as she needs to be able to write
catalog notes and labels correctly in her second language. I also want to
help her develop confidence in people skills, an area she already has well
under control but encounters some initial difficulty (with English speakers)
as she has hearing aids. We will be working together about eight hours a
week, and she will also work independently and with other volunteers. She
will be paid for this internship, so it behooves me to train her well and
quickly.
One other problem, or I think of it as a potential problem. The museum
manager thinks of the intern now as a Curator, which I am not comfortable
with because she lacks on-the-ground experience and even has some academic
gaps, and collections management is not her field of study (cross-cultural
museum education is). It's a bit awkward, I don't want her to think you can
take a course or two and get a paid job as a Curator of Collections-- and
everyone on this list knows that is pretty much a fantasy. How on earth am I
to handle this-- I want to increase her confidence, not belittle her lack of
experience or seem to conflict with another authority. I noticed that the
museum manager already made a permanent badge for her that says Curator, not
Intern. Admittedly, I am thinking of my full year as a 20-hour a week unpaid
intern before I even graduated, and I need to get that undercurrent of
resentment out of the picture too!
Thank you all, my wonderful colleagues, for any responses you can provide.
Micki Ryan
Curator
Highline Historical Society
[log in to unmask]
Pamela Silvestri, Museum Assistant
Northeast States Civilian Conservation Corps Museum
Shenipsit State Forest
166 Chestnut Hill Road
Stafford Springs, Connecticut 06076
(860) 684-3430
=========================================================
Important Subscriber Information:
The Museum-L FAQ file is located at http://www.finalchapter.com/museum-l-faq/ . You may obtain detailed information about the listserv commands by sending a one line e-mail message to [log in to unmask] . The body of the message should read "help" (without the quotes).
If you decide to leave Museum-L, please send a one line e-mail message to [log in to unmask] . The body of the message should read "Signoff Museum-L" (without the quotes).
|