Dear Bing,

Speaking of learning history, your interpretation of 20th century
history is rather spotty.

(I recommend that peace museums conduct programming in world history as
a key element of their lifelong learning activities.)

WW2 was fought over colonies and the natural resources therein. It was
very much connected to oil, especially, which was an important
condition in both the war along the Pacific Rim and Hitler's drive to
the Baku oil fields. (Not coincidentally, a coveted area today.)  Oil
was very clearly a major trigger for the Japan-US conflict, and the
attack on the US fleet in Hawaii was connected to the oil embargo of
Japan. Certainly one of the major resources coming out of what is now
Indonesia (and coastal Vietnam) is oil. c.f. Royal Dutch / Shell.

At least some in government in England (such as Churchill) and the US
favored pushing Germany toward the USSR in the hopes of doing it in.
The fact that the USSR decisively defeated Germany on that front
explains both how that war was actually decided and why a second front
in Europe was finally opened in June 1944 - some 15 months after the
German defeat on the Russian front - to try and occupy France and
points east before the Red Army could.

Chamberlain wasn't trying to secure peace in Europe as some abstract
concept, he was trying to buy some time for England to prepare for the
coming conflict.

If anything, the maneuvering by the so-called Allied and Axis powers
before hostilities commenced is a clear example of how it didn't really
matter who fired the first shot. As Clausewitz observed in general and
a century earlier, the coming war was the continuation of their
politics by other, violent, means.

It is incorrect to blame pacifists for WW2.

-L.D.


On Wednesday, July 21, 2004, at 12:04 AM, Automatic digest processor
wrote:

 > Date:    Mon, 19 Jul 2004 20:45:10 -0700
 > From:    "John A. Bing" <[log in to unmask]>
 > Subject: Re: Stonewalk
 >
 > I have restrained myself from entering this thread as I viewed it as a
 > rather naive effort of claiming that one could make war go away by
 > just being nice and not having an army.  It makes me wonder if they
 > still teach history in our schools.  I also wonder if the proponents
 > of no army are just doing this as a political message for the coming
 > election.  A few points:
 >
 > Did anyone think of how many fewer millions of people would have been
 > killed in WWII if Chamberlain had taken a strong stand to Hitler
 > instead of relying on Hitler's assurance on non aggression.  We all
 > can take a lesson by watching the old newsreel of Chamberlain getting
 > out of the airplane and holding up a piece of paper and claiming that
 > because of his agreement with Hitler there will be "..peace in our
 > times..." Ha.
 >
 > Hitler invaded Poland  and Russia not because they had armies but
 > because they had small armies that he could conquer.
 >
 > Ask the people of Belgian and Luxembourg, both of which had minuscule
 > armies what their "peace" was during WWI as well as in WWII.
 >
 > Lastly, if you are repulsed by war, shooting and hurting people, why
 > don't you get rid of the police.  They are just the communities's
 > equivalent of an army.  Just think how your lives would change if we
 > didn't have our police or as they are often referred to as "peace
 > officers." You can be sure it would find us all hunkering down in our
 > houses scared to go out because of all the thugs and robbers out
 > there.
 >
 > We need our police and we need our army and, we need to stop the
 > Hitlers and el Quida BEFORE they do us harm.  The only point is that
 > firm and factual justification will only come when they write the
 > history, and if you are wrong, you probably won't be around to read
 > it.
 > John Bing

=========================================================
Important Subscriber Information:

The Museum-L FAQ file is located at http://www.finalchapter.com/museum-l-faq/ . You may obtain detailed information about the listserv commands by sending a one line e-mail message to [log in to unmask] . The body of the message should read "help" (without the quotes).

If you decide to leave Museum-L, please send a one line e-mail message to [log in to unmask] . The body of the message should read "Signoff Museum-L" (without the quotes).