[quoting Janice Klein, The Field Museum
[log in to unmask]:

Subj: Expert Advice

A deep sigh... At the risk of being flamed, I need to support
Diane Gutenkauf's postings about the use of expert advice....

end of quote]

At the same risk, I add my support.  In my field (history) you don't
need a license to express an opinion, and it's stimulating to read and
participate in debates on historical topics, on MUSEUM-L and elsewhere.
Sometimes, however, requests appear on MUSEUM-L asking for specific
factual historical information that someone needs as part of a program
or exhibit.  These requests are often answered with helpful references
to experts, libraries, or particular written sources that can provide
accurate answers.

Unfortunately, these requests also tend to draw unfounded speculation
and erroneous guesses from well-trained botanists, astronomers, and
others who recall that they may have once read a book about the subject
in question.  These kinds of comments are no more helpful to the poster
than would be my advice on wasp removal.

Gutenkauf was accused of "condescension" for expressing the pain she
felt watching amateurs spread misinformation.  I feel your pain.

Gerry Prokopowicz, Ph. D.
The Lincoln Museum
Fort Wayne, IN
[log in to unmask]